New Moon: Something Like a Review.

November 30, 2009 |

new-moon-trailer-2

Stephenie Meyer’s Twilight franchise is arguably the most popular young adult series in the market today. Anyone who argues this statement is an idiot. If you watch television, spend a considerable amount of time online, or go outdoors and talk to people, then you will have heard of Edward Cullen, a “vampire,” and his unmatched love story with Bella Swan — holy crap! — a mortal. Lots of stuff happens in between but that is the main idea and Meyer hammers that into her audience’s head time and time again.

I have not been a very big fan of Twilight. On the contrary, I’ve spent many a-time online devoted to its mockery. A week and a half after New Moon, the much-awaited Twilight sequel’s adaptation to film, opened here and I still had not been able to see it. Until 10:00 P.M. tonight, when the lure to mock the series intelligently was too great for me to ignore for another week.


And so, I watched it alone.

In case you were interested, New Moon in a nutshell: loads of heavy breathing (not due to sexual activity), fast cars, glittery people with weird colored eyes, Jacob Black!, wolves!, sage advice completely ignored by Bella, and “intense” close-ups and slow-motion sequences chosen to convey several emotions… I’m just never sure what kind.

New Moon in an even smaller nutshell: Facepalm (but sounds good, man!)

In case you are still interested, The Unabridged Version of My Aversion To Twilight will be under the cut. To be fair, I do have some nice things to say about the movie. But, a word of warning, there’s not really a lot of nice things I can say about this movie. So, leave if you think you might be a little sentimental or protective of the characters in Meyer’s universe.

New Moon is, essentially, about how Edward Cullen realizes how he is endangering the life of the woman he loves and, in effect, decides to make her believe that she is not good enough for him. And then, he leaves her in the woods, promising never to show his face to her again.

Bella undergoes traumatic after-effects (nightmares, depression, self-alienation from her friends) and the life that Edward wanted her to have — “a normal, happy life” — is still evasive, since she is wallowing in her room, piteously, as the crafty cinematography shows how months pass in a continuous shot of Bella, unmoving in her chair, the seasons changing outside her window (to a very awesome song).

new_moon_jacob_bella_gaze

In the middle of everything, there is a realization that putting herself in any kind of danger is the only time that she can “see” Edward, in the form of visions, so she decides to enlist her friend Jacob Black’s help to refurbish two worn-out motorcycles she magically was able to salvage from a junkyard. The time they spend together causes sexual tension, during which Bella refers to her 18-year-old self as a “cougar” and rejects any sort of advancement Jacob extends towards her, despite the fact that he’d inadvertently been helping her cope with the loss of “the love of her life.”

Very early into the movie, Charlie Swan, Bella’s dad tells her a very important lesson (in life, and in this particular situation): “Sometimes, you gotta learn to love what’s good for you.” Charlie is actually one of the people Meyer has crafted that I can stand, and this is, honestly, very sage advice. Bella, however, throws it out of the window and fights the feelings she had been developing for Jacob, and when he gets rejected after what feels like a thousand times, he stops returning her calls.

Because she is selfish and needs Jacob in her life, she hunts him down, sees that he’s changed and that he seems to not want to be around her anymore. She gets herself into even more danger, gets rescued by Jacob Black (because he is awesome) and finds out about the truth about him and how exactly he has changed.

Bella and Jacob

My favorite parts of the movie are actually the ones with all the werewolves in them. I am, admittedly, mostly drawn to broody types (Marcus Flutie, Jordan Catalano, Tim Riggins), but Edward Cullen broods himself to no end. At least Meyer got the metaphor right when it came to Jacob. In a scene that I am quite fond of, Bella tells him: “You’re warm. You’re like your own sun.” And maybe it’s a personal bias. I rooted for the Lycans in Underworld, and Remus Lupin is my favorite character in the Harry Potter series. But there is something in the way Meyer writes her vampires that makes me want to stab my eyes.

It’s a very complicated story with pointless twists and plotlines, and I can rant about the weaknesses of the Twilight saga and how it seems to totally ignore the mythology behind vampires, et cetera, et cetera. But I find that I am most bothered by the fact that instead of creating a powerful female figure, Meyer is trying to revive the helpless damsel who gets herself into trouble. All. The. Frakking. Time.

oversized

On the surface, she seems to have crafted the ideal, independent girl for the modern age: Bella does not like shopping and likes zombie flicks. She drives a truck and listens to “Claire de Lune” and she wears an olive green jacket two sizes too big for her, an oversized look which, if I can point out, was first done by Angela Chase and Lindsay Weir. The scene where Bella leaves the movies with her friend Jessica is constructed to make Jessica look vapid next to her, but instead it brought to my attention how insightful and intelligent Jessica is, as opposed to Bella, whose sole mission in life seems to be to get herself into trouble because that seems to be the only way to get Edward’s attention. At least Jessica was smart enough not to get on a motorcycle with some creeper in an alley, catcalling her.

What frustrates me more than the gross exchange between Edward and Bella (whose love seems to be founded on nothing, by the way) and the inexplicable advances, or lack thereof, of her relationships, is the fact that whatever seems the most sensible thing to do is always clear to everyone. Bella just happens to be set on doing what seems to be the opposite of what everyone thinks is right for her — for very stupid reasons.

heroines

I know there are grey areas and things are never really just right and wrong, but people like Joss Whedon and Russell T. Davies have been creating powerful female characters like Buffy Summers and Rose Tyler, and Stephenie Meyer seems intent on driving a stake through their hearts and killing them, in favor of such a weak and ridiculous character like Bella Swan. I don’t like the portrayal of vampires (no death by sunlight? By stake? No? Oh, okay) and I don’t like how stupid Edward and Bella’s “love” is, but my main issue is how Meyer has been effectively destroying the image of women, preaching really dumb ideas to her enormous fanbase. This is my main issue.

“I want to be like Bella Swan.” Who in their right mind would say that?

Things that I did like:

  1. The soundtrack was obviously good.
  2. Taylor Lautner turned out good. And also, every single one of the werewolves were hot. Paul was especially attractive.
  3. They were mostly half-naked the entire time.
  4. First time that I did not hate Rosalie.
  5. Dakota Fanning was awesome.
  6. The special effects improved from the first film.
  7. Jacob Black!
  8. Charlie Swan.
  9. The change of setting was nice.
  10. Jacob Black.

And so. I leave you with a few thoughts:

  1. Bella, you are stupid.
  2. Stop ignoring what everybody says!
  3. I am afraid of the ideas this generation is getting from this saga.
  4. Vampires burn in the sun and also die by stakes. Don’t create your own immortal beings, write off a few hundred years’ worth of culture and lore, and call them ‘vampires.’ Don’t be dumb.
  5. I cannot wait for Breaking Dawn.
  6. It makes me sad what she has in store for Jacob’s character. :(
  7. How the frak was Taylor Lautner born in 1992?

alg_actor_taylor-lautner

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

  1. Helga says:

    I just downloaded Cheaper By The Dozen 2 and I’m planning on naming my next dog Mr Black. Gademet, why must Lautner (even with his nose) be so nomnommable!

    And and and I LOVED New Moon! It’s like they thought “LOL fuck you all, we’re not even going to put any effort into making this a good movie because we know we’re going to make millions anyway. Suckas.” That last scene, I swear. “Gasp!” ROFLWAFFLEZ.

  2. Shinji says:

    WHY, OH WHY?! You made me want to see New Moon!!!

  3. Sasha says:

    DUDE WE SHOULD HAVE WATCHED THIS TOGETHER. O_o I know what you mean, about snarking intelligently. It’s why I read all four excruciating books–so I have basis when I tear them a new one, haha.

    That said–do you wonder how they’ll pull off the absolute horror of the last book?

    PS For shame, when Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire came out, I sat up straighter when Cedric Diggory was introduced. Cedric > Edward.

    PPS Eric Northaman > Edward Cullen, since we’re on the subject of vampires. Oh, and that dude from the Jeaniene Frost books. And that dude from the Karen Marie Moning books, although I don’t think he’s a vampire.

    Gah, babble babble. :)

  4. Reggie says:

    BB, ILY SO! A+. Everything you wrote is truth!

    The wolf pack totes has more personality and chemistry than the Cullens!

    (But I still love Flatface despite his wooden acting. KMN.)

  5. Zee says:

    XD Love this review. Now I want to hear you really rant about what you think about the whole saga. :P

  6. Martin says:

    I wanna see for myself tuloy HAHA.

  7. Macy says:

    YES to everything in this post!

    Also, JACOB! Imagine how I feel… I was born in 1982! O: HAHA!

  8. Carina says:

    Helga, FUUUU he was in Cheaper By the Dozen 2? I only saw the first one. For obvious reasons. Would you believe he was supposed to be recast? And he buffed himself and now, aww, the world is a better place. <3

    Shinji, you didn’t??! Go see it!

    Sasha, I bet they are wondering that themselves. Perhaps they are cursing that horrible mormom woman for writing such stupid things, and also the general public that eats it up anyway.

    Hearts for Cedric Diggory forever! He was such a cuteface. Every time Edward Cullen appears onscreen, I want to kill myself because he looks so pained alllll the time. LOOOOL. I don’t follow True Blood :) But I will agree with you by saying Spike > Edward Cullen.

  9. Mela Migz says:

    i think the 2nd movie is way better than the first one — in terms of acting (although it didn’t change that much), effects (FX), and they have achieved a fine representation of Jacob Black and the werewolves.

  10. Carina says:

    Reggie, sry bb but I really don’t get it. :((( I would never kill you, though! <3 My soft spot for RPattz has forever been fixed into place by Cedric Diggory. NEVER FORGET!

    Zee, Hai Zee! I’ve only really read until about a third of New Moon, but these films really make me want to read them all. I do know what happens in the end, though. Just not the specifics. Which is pretty much how I like my Twilight.

    Martin, bb you know I’d see this again with you~ LOOOOL. I was constrained by my loner-ness, fearing that LOL-ing would get me pelted by rocks. So I settled for quiet indignation.

    Macy, Yay! Also, I am so sorry for your loss. February 11th will be a momentous day for us all. (!)

  11. Carina says:

    Mela Migz, I agree with everything you said. The acting was weird, though. I mean, I didn’t remember it sucking so bad in the first film. Maybe I expected it to suck then, and now I expected it to have improved and then it didn’t, really… D: Thanks for reading, by the way!

  12. aziel says:

    I agree with everything that you said. I actually like Jacob. My friend said that “he gave her self respect, which she rejected time and time again.”

    For me, the movie just highlighted on how dumb Bella’s character really is. Jacob, Charlie, Jessica… they were suppose to somehow contrast Bella’s pain or you know, enhance her character in some way. However, the movie made me like these supporting characters more and dislike Bella Swan.

    Especially the scene with Rosalie where she stated her reasons for saying no and everyone in the cullen family was saying yes. The whole time I was thinking, “Seriously, people love this. People want to be Bella. WHY? WHY?” I suppose the goal of the film was suppose to endear you to Bella and Edward’s love story. But a main character who acts like she can’t even respect herself enough to be independent is hard to digest.

    Oh, if it came to a choice. Team Jacob. He was cute, broody, and funny. And she didn’t need him obsessively like she did Edward.On the other hand, Edward for me has no redeemable qualities. I mean handsome, sparkling, and angsty can only get you so far right?

    Oh and this made me smile. It was cute

    Bella “Im freezing
    Jacob “Hello it’s 108 degrees over here”
    Bella gets closer “must be nice being warm all the time
    Jacob “I guess its just a warewolf thing
    Bella “No. Its a Jacob thing”

  13. Bernadette says:

    Haha, I still haven’t watched New Moon and I’m afraid to. @_@; Baka magkaroon ako ng permanent head damage from all the times that I will be banging my head on the seat in front of me.

  14. Carina says:

    Cola, waiting very, very patiently, although I guess the release date hasn’t been announced. Holy crap, how cool would that movie be? Congratulations, Smeyer, for shooting yourself in the foot.

    Aziel, LOL IKR. I love Jacob Black. ;___; I honestly inwardly groaned when they showed his face onscreen again. Hahaha sadface.

    Bea, haha it was alright. Terrible story, but it’s not like I had high expectations or anything.

  15. Laurene says:

    I completely agree with you especially on Bella’s perfection-gone-wrong. Meyer obviously tried to make her character so ideal by making her “different” and giving her unconventional interests, but her efforts made everything strained (somebody so standoffish turns out to be well-liked?).

    Aside from that, I’d say that there were some good points in the movie (Dakota Fanning who is just too nice to see even if the movie is New Moon, Taylor Lautner and all his hot werewolf friends) while the rest were cheesy and not in a good way.

  16. Gabe says:

    So funeeeh!!

    Im a fan of your blooog! la lang. bwahahaha!

    pero sobrang fan girl ng mom ko! hahaha! after watching twilight last year, she bought all four books and finished reading all of it in six weeks. and nag-advance reserve siya for new moon. hahaha!

  17. Carina says:

    Laurene, wow this comment back is way late. Sorry~ I agree that the film had its moments, especially since I am pretty much inclined towards Jacob Black, but yeah, I did not like it so much.

    GAAAAABE THANK YOU FOR READING. I HAVE NO READERSHIP HAHAHA. Medyo thankful lang ako na hindi nagbabasa ng libro ang nanay ko. :( Haha medyo malungkot (na nakakatawa?) ‘pag nanay mo mahilig sa Twilight. HEHEHE.

Leave a Reply

NOTHING SPACES
© Carina Santos 2009-2011. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by WordPress. Modified Hiperminimalist. (Colophon?)

SUBSCRIBE:
Entries (RSS)
Comments (RSS)



LINKwithlove

I like making things and writing. Sometimes, I read. When I grow up, I want to make books.

ELSEWHERE:
Maybe Very Happy
Pelikula
Recovery

Log in